Do Not Recommend

Broadway Auto Transport

Legal entity: Broadway Auto Transport LLC

Operating-authority discrepancy in the supplied SAFER record; clarify before booking.

Read the full assessment

The October 10, 2026 SAFER snapshot lists ACTIVE USDOT registration but NOT AUTHORIZED operating authority, with entity type CARRIER. These are different statuses. The snapshot notes that NOT AUTHORIZED does not apply to private or intrastate operations; it does not establish active interstate brokerage authority for this listing. Trustpilot shows 4.5/5 from 155 reviews and BBB customer reviews show 4.05/5 from 111. Positive accounts describe successful shipments and helpful representatives. Favorable review averages do not resolve the authority discrepancy. Yelp shows 1.8/5 from 38 reviews. BBB lists a C+ grade and 44 complaints over three years, 12 in the last 12 months. Critical accounts describe higher replacement offers, unfilled pickup windows and refund disputes. Similar $1,200/$300-deposit accounts appear across platforms and must not be counted as separate verified shipments. Source evidence reviewed October 12, 2026; the existing 34/100 score is historical and was not recalculated from this upload.

Sources reviewed: October 12, 2026 · Historical audit: April 2026 · Auditor: Kol · MC MC-1496533 · USDOT 3990000

No customer reviews here yet · Verify Car Carrier

Read reviewsWrite a reviewRequest a quote

Editorial assessment · not a customer rating

34
out of 100

Historical audit score · not recalculated in the October source review

Broadway Auto Transport · Customer experiences

Reviews on Verify Car Carrier

Experiences submitted to this platform. These reviews are separate from external ratings and our editorial research; their scores are never combined.

Share your experience

A space for your experience

No customer reviews here yet

Have you shipped with Broadway Auto Transport? Share what happened, from booking to delivery, to help the next shipper. External ratings and editorial findings are not customer reviews on this platform.

Write a review

Tell other shippers about your own experience with Broadway Auto Transport. An optional order reference does not mean the shipment has been independently verified. Do not include order numbers or private information in your public review.

Share your own shipment experience. Submissions pass platform checks before publication; those checks do not independently verify a shipment.

Checking your reviewer identity…

Your rating *

Only the last 4 characters are stored. A reference does not independently verify a shipment. Never share full payment info here.

Supporting files (optional)

Up to 5 files per category, 10 MB each. Shipment photos are public. Contracts and bills of lading stay private unless you choose public sharing below. Remove addresses, signatures, account details, medical information and other sensitive content before sharing. Public files can be viewed and downloaded by anyone.

Company research · Evidence at a glance

Broadway Auto Transport: what the evidence shows

Identity records, external platform snapshots, and booking considerations. This is company research, not customer reviews submitted to VerifyCarCarrier or verification of an individual shipment.

Stored research snapshotEvidence checked: October 12, 2026Research by Kol

External reputation

Stored platform snapshots, not live ratings. A BBB business grade is not a customer star rating.

Google

4.7/ 5

External customer-review platform

1,741 reviews

Read Google source
Google evidence notes

Owner-provided snapshot, October 12, 2026; not independently verified.

How to read these snapshots

Platforms use different review policies and samples. Reviews may be cross-posted; counts are not added together and no combined rating is calculated. Withheld or missing values are not estimates. The evidence check date is not necessarily each platform’s capture date. Follow the original sources for current ratings, review text, and reporting periods.

BBB record & complaint context

Not BBB accredited in the stored evidence.

Complaints · one-year period
12
Complaints · three-year period
44
Read BBB record
Complaint-count limitations

Reporting-window end dates, complaint categories, outcomes, and a shipment-volume denominator are not established by these counts. One-year and three-year periods can overlap; do not add them together. Counts do not establish a shipment failure rate. Missing data does not mean no complaints. Read the BBB source for current context.

Research limitations & source directory

Company research and editorial assessments are not customer-review scores, insurance guarantees, or promises of future performance. Stored evidence may change after the check date.

Identity & authority

Broadway Auto Transport LLC

Doing business as Broadway Auto Transport

MC number
MC-1496533
USDOT number
3990000
State
NY
FMCSA authority
Inactive · stored record

Identifiers alone do not establish active broker authority. Read the current federal record before booking; this is not a live authority check.

The October 10, 2026 SAFER snapshot lists ACTIVE USDOT registration but NOT AUTHORIZED operating authority, with entity type CARRIER. These are different statuses. The snapshot notes that NOT AUTHORIZED does not apply to private or intrastate operations; it does not establish active interstate brokerage authority for this listing.

Business history

January 5, 2023 — business started (BBB)

3 completed years as of October 12, 2026.

View business-history source ↗

Business age is not proof of uninterrupted authority or shipment experience. A recorded number of years is not used to infer a founding date.

Terms & shipment fit

Pricing approach
Budget
Price risk · research assessment
High
Suggested fit · research assessment
none
Full booking research notes

No

Open transport
Weak
Enclosed transport
Weak
Urgent pickup
Weak
Luxury vehicles
Weak
Inoperable vehicles
Weak

Fit labels are editorial assessments, not guaranteed availability or shipment outcomes.

Positive research signals

  • Trustpilot shows 4.5/5 from 155 reviews and BBB customer reviews show 4.05/5 from 111. Positive accounts describe successful shipments and helpful representatives. Favorable review averages do not resolve the authority discrepancy.

Research cautions

  • Yelp shows 1.8/5 from 38 reviews. BBB lists a C+ grade and 44 complaints over three years, 12 in the last 12 months. Critical accounts describe higher replacement offers, unfilled pickup windows and refund disputes. Similar $1,200/$300-deposit accounts appear across platforms and must not be counted as separate verified shipments.
  • The October 10, 2026 SAFER snapshot lists ACTIVE USDOT registration but NOT AUTHORIZED operating authority, with entity type CARRIER. These are different statuses. The snapshot notes that NOT AUTHORIZED does not apply to private or intrastate operations; it does not establish active interstate brokerage authority for this listing.
Detailed source reviewRead evidence and details

Source review · October 12, 2026 · 10 saved pages

Broadway Auto Transport: authority, review evidence, and booking cautions

This review separates federal registration, platform ratings, complaints and company responses. The documents are dated snapshots, not live checks. The existing 34/100 audit has not been recalculated from this evidence.

Federal record and authority scope

USDOT 3990000 · MC-1496533

The October 10, 2026 SAFER snapshot lists ACTIVE USDOT registration but NOT AUTHORIZED operating authority, with entity type CARRIER. These are different statuses. The snapshot notes that NOT AUTHORIZED does not apply to private or intrastate operations; it does not establish active interstate brokerage authority for this listing.

An active USDOT registration is not the same as appropriate operating authority. A broker’s inspection history does not establish the safety of the assigned carrier.

View federal source ↗

Business identity and history

BROADWAY AUTO TRANSPORT LLC is listed at 1 Maiden Lane, New York. In BBB responses the business describes itself as a broker, while the supplied SAFER record classifies this DOT identity as a carrier. Require current licensing clarification before paying; do not substitute another entity’s authorization.

Business started: January 5, 2023 (BBB)

Business start, incorporation, registration and filing dates are different events. None alone proves uninterrupted operations.

Platform evidence—not a combined rating

BBB grades are not customer stars. Different platforms use different review samples, dates and moderation rules; their totals must not be added together as unique shipments.

Google

4.7 / 5 · 1,741 reviews

Owner-provided snapshot, October 12, 2026; not independently verified.

View Google source ↗

BBB

Transport Reviews

Trustpilot

4.5 / 5 · 155 reviewsView Trustpilot source ↗

Yelp

1.8 / 5 · 38 reviewsView Yelp source ↗

BBB customer reviews

ConsumerAffairs

Rating not establishedView ConsumerAffairs source ↗

What customers praise

Trustpilot shows 4.5/5 from 155 reviews and BBB customer reviews show 4.05/5 from 111. Positive accounts describe successful shipments and helpful representatives. Favorable review averages do not resolve the authority discrepancy.

Concerns raised in the documents

Yelp shows 1.8/5 from 38 reviews. BBB lists a C+ grade and 44 complaints over three years, 12 in the last 12 months. Critical accounts describe higher replacement offers, unfilled pickup windows and refund disputes. Similar $1,200/$300-deposit accounts appear across platforms and must not be counted as separate verified shipments.

These are attributed accounts, not independently verified findings. Negative-filtered pages cannot establish how often a problem occurs.

What to confirm before booking with Broadway Auto Transport

Do not pay until the contracting entity and appropriate current authority are clear. Then confirm the final carrier price, broker fee, cancellation rules and any refund entitlement if a carrier cannot be found at the original estimate.

  • Match the legal entity and MC/USDOT identifiers on your agreement to current federal records.
  • Get the final price, broker fee, payment timing and refund conditions in writing.
  • Ask what happens if the initial carrier cancels or requests a different price.
  • Distinguish estimated pickup windows from any written guarantee.
  • Verify the assigned carrier’s authority, cargo coverage and damage-claim contact.

The saved material does not establish a complaint rate without shipment volume, current availability on every route, or a guaranteed future outcome. Reviews and business replies can disagree; neither side’s claim is treated as independently proven.

Is Broadway Auto Transport a Legitimate Business?Authority, Licensing & FMCSA ComplianceRead evidence and details
1

Is Broadway Auto Transport a Legitimate Business?

Authority, Licensing & FMCSA Compliance

MC Number

MC-1496533

USDOT Number

3990000

Business started (BBB)

2023-01-05

USDOT 3990000 · MC-1496533. The October 10, 2026 SAFER snapshot lists ACTIVE USDOT registration but NOT AUTHORIZED operating authority, with entity type CARRIER. These are different statuses. The snapshot notes that NOT AUTHORIZED does not apply to private or intrastate operations; it does not establish active interstate brokerage authority for this listing. BROADWAY AUTO TRANSPORT LLC is listed at 1 Maiden Lane, New York. In BBB responses the business describes itself as a broker, while the supplied SAFER record classifies this DOT identity as a carrier. Require current licensing clarification before paying; do not substitute another entity’s authorization. A broker’s zero-inspection record is not evidence of a carrier’s safety performance.

January 5, 2023 — business started (BBB)

3 completed years as of October 12, 2026.

View business-history source ↗
Verify FMCSA Record ↗
Broadway Auto Transport Reviews & ReputationWhat real customers are saying across platformsRead evidence and details
2

Broadway Auto Transport Reviews & Reputation

What real customers are saying across platforms

Google 4.7/5 from 1,741 reviews (Owner-provided snapshot, October 12, 2026; not independently verified.). Trustpilot 4.5/5 from 155 reviews. Yelp 1.8/5 from 38 reviews. Transport Reviews 4/5 with 30 reviews displayed on the supplied profile; its star rating uses the last two years. BBB business grade C+; customer reviews 4.05/5 from 111 reviews; not accredited. Yelp shows 1.8/5 from 38 reviews. BBB lists a C+ grade and 44 complaints over three years, 12 in the last 12 months. Critical accounts describe higher replacement offers, unfilled pickup windows and refund disputes. Similar $1,200/$300-deposit accounts appear across platforms and must not be counted as separate verified shipments. Broadway’s September BBB response says a disputed transaction was fully refunded; another response explains that it acts as a broker and that prices and pickup dates are estimates. These are the company’s responses, not independent proof of every claimed resolution. BBB distinguishes 27 answered complaints from 17 resolved complaints.

Customer ExperienceCommunication, pickup, delivery and issue resolutionRead evidence and details
3

Customer Experience

Communication, pickup, delivery and issue resolution

Trustpilot shows 4.5/5 from 155 reviews and BBB customer reviews show 4.05/5 from 111. Positive accounts describe successful shipments and helpful representatives. Favorable review averages do not resolve the authority discrepancy. Yelp shows 1.8/5 from 38 reviews. BBB lists a C+ grade and 44 complaints over three years, 12 in the last 12 months. Critical accounts describe higher replacement offers, unfilled pickup windows and refund disputes. Similar $1,200/$300-deposit accounts appear across platforms and must not be counted as separate verified shipments. Broadway’s September BBB response says a disputed transaction was fully refunded; another response explains that it acts as a broker and that prices and pickup dates are estimates. These are the company’s responses, not independent proof of every claimed resolution. BBB distinguishes 27 answered complaints from 17 resolved complaints. These are published accounts, not independently verified shipments. Similar stories across platforms may describe the same transaction.

Broadway Auto Transport PricingCost, value, and price consistencyRead evidence and details
4

Broadway Auto Transport Pricing

Cost, value, and price consistency

Pricing Style

Budget

Price-Change Risk

High

Best For

none

Do not pay until the contracting entity and appropriate current authority are clear. Then confirm the final carrier price, broker fee, cancellation rules and any refund entitlement if a carrier cannot be found at the original estimate.

Routes & Service CoverageGeographic reach and transport types offeredRead evidence and details
5

Routes & Service Coverage

Geographic reach and transport types offered

Transport Types Audited

✕Open TransportWeak
✕EnclosedWeak
✕Urgent PickupWeak
✕Luxury / ClassicWeak
✕Inoperable CarsWeak

The supplied pages do not establish measured performance on every route or transport type. Confirm the actual carrier, pickup window, vehicle condition requirements and any terminal or ocean segment. Individual review prices are historical examples, not current lane quotes.

Brand Transparency & Online PresenceWebsite quality, review handling, and trust signalsRead evidence and details
6

Brand Transparency & Online Presence

Website quality, review handling, and trust signals

BROADWAY AUTO TRANSPORT LLC is listed at 1 Maiden Lane, New York. In BBB responses the business describes itself as a broker, while the supplied SAFER record classifies this DOT identity as a carrier. Require current licensing clarification before paying; do not substitute another entity’s authorization. This update uses 10 user-supplied saved pages reviewed October 12, 2026, not live platform checks. Filtered negative pages overlap the main profiles and must not be added to their totals. Company replies are attributed claims; answered complaints are not necessarily resolved. Owner-provided snapshot, October 12, 2026; not independently verified. Source evidence reviewed October 12, 2026; the existing 34/100 score is historical and was not recalculated from this upload.

Final assessment and supporting reasonsRead the editorial recommendation, supporting reasons and limitations. This is separate from customer ratings.Read evidence and details
7

Final Verdict

Our full audit conclusion

Do Not Recommend
34/100

The October 10, 2026 SAFER snapshot lists ACTIVE USDOT registration but NOT AUTHORIZED operating authority, with entity type CARRIER. These are different statuses. The snapshot notes that NOT AUTHORIZED does not apply to private or intrastate operations; it does not establish active interstate brokerage authority for this listing. Trustpilot shows 4.5/5 from 155 reviews and BBB customer reviews show 4.05/5 from 111. Positive accounts describe successful shipments and helpful representatives. Favorable review averages do not resolve the authority discrepancy. Yelp shows 1.8/5 from 38 reviews. BBB lists a C+ grade and 44 complaints over three years, 12 in the last 12 months. Critical accounts describe higher replacement offers, unfilled pickup windows and refund disputes. Similar $1,200/$300-deposit accounts appear across platforms and must not be counted as separate verified shipments. Source evidence reviewed October 12, 2026; the existing 34/100 score is historical and was not recalculated from this upload.

Recommendation: We do not recommend this broker.

✓ What's Working

  • ●Trustpilot shows 4.5/5 from 155 reviews and BBB customer reviews show 4.05/5 from 111. Positive accounts describe successful shipments and helpful representatives. Favorable review averages do not resolve the authority discrepancy.

⚠ Watch Out For

  • ●Yelp shows 1.8/5 from 38 reviews. BBB lists a C+ grade and 44 complaints over three years, 12 in the last 12 months. Critical accounts describe higher replacement offers, unfilled pickup windows and refund disputes. Similar $1,200/$300-deposit accounts appear across platforms and must not be counted as separate verified shipments.
  • ●The October 10, 2026 SAFER snapshot lists ACTIVE USDOT registration but NOT AUTHORIZED operating authority, with entity type CARRIER. These are different statuses. The snapshot notes that NOT AUTHORIZED does not apply to private or intrastate operations; it does not establish active interstate brokerage authority for this listing.

Ready to ship?

Get matched with Broadway Auto Transport

Submit your shipment details and we'll forward your inquiry directly to this broker. Free referral — Verify Car Carrier doesn't arrange transport or take payment.

Get Matched →

Broadway Auto Transport

34/100 · Do Not Recommend

Get Matched →

How this score was calculated

This is a public-source desk audit using our existing scoring formula, not a shipment test. Customer-experience categories use review signals as proxies. Unknown route suitability is not treated as proven poor performance.

  • Source evidence reviewed October 12, 2026; the existing 34/100 score is historical and was not recalculated from this upload.

Compare Broadway Auto Transport with other companies

Explore alternatives, prioritizing companies based in the same state, then independent audit score. These are not shipment guarantees.

Common Questions

Frequently asked about Broadway Auto Transport

Is Broadway Auto Transport a legitimate auto transport broker?

The October 10, 2026 SAFER snapshot lists ACTIVE USDOT registration but NOT AUTHORIZED operating authority, with entity type CARRIER. These are different statuses. The snapshot notes that NOT AUTHORIZED does not apply to private or intrastate operations; it does not establish active interstate brokerage authority for this listing. Our desk-audit score is 34/100 — Do Not Recommend.

What is Broadway Auto Transport's trust score?

Broadway Auto Transport received a trust score of 34 out of 100 in the Verify Car Carrier independent audit. This score is based on six weighted categories: FMCSA legitimacy, reputation, customer experience, pricing integrity, route fit, and brand transparency. The October 12, 2026 source update did not recalculate this historical score.

Is Broadway Auto Transport recommended for auto transport?

Broadway Auto Transport is rated "Do Not Recommend" by Verify Car Carrier. This means we do not recommend this broker based on our audit findings.

How long has Broadway Auto Transport been in business?

BROADWAY AUTO TRANSPORT LLC is listed at 1 Maiden Lane, New York. In BBB responses the business describes itself as a broker, while the supplied SAFER record classifies this DOT identity as a carrier. Require current licensing clarification before paying; do not substitute another entity’s authorization. Registration and filing dates should not be treated as proof of continuous operating history.

Does Broadway Auto Transport pay to appear on Verify Car Carrier?

No. Broadway Auto Transport does not pay to appear on Verify Car Carrier, and no broker can pay to improve their score or remove a negative verdict. Every audit score is earned based on FMCSA records and verified review data.