Quick answer
A close comparison—fit matters more than a small score difference
AllStatetoStateAutoTransport has a 1-point edge in the current audit score. That is not enough on its own to settle the decision. Use the service fit, pricing approach, and documented caveats below to decide which option better matches your shipment.
Your shipment. Your choice of company.
Request a quote from the company you choose. Company contact and a shipment-specific quote come next—not an instant price.
How to use this comparison
Choose based on your shipment—not a headline score alone
The score is a useful starting point, but price certainty, vehicle type, pickup urgency, and the quality of the assigned carrier matter too. We compare audited signals instead of selling rank positions, then link to the underlying broker reports so you can verify the evidence before you request quotes.
Best fit by situation
When each broker may make more sense
AllStatetoStateAutoTransport
50/100 · Limited Confidence
- •none shipping is a stated overall fit
Auto Haul Express LLC or AutoCarShip LLC
49/100 · Limited Confidence
- •Standard Open shipping is a stated overall fit
- •strong audited fits: enclosed transport and urgent pickup
- •2 years in business adds operating history
Broker-by-broker analysis
What the audited evidence says
AllStatetoStateAutoTransport
50/100 · Limited Confidence · Audited April 6, 2026
All State to State Auto Transport scores 88/100 — Top Recommended. BISMILLAH TRANSPORT LLC holds active FMCSA broker authority under MC-653413 / USDOT 2242737, has an A+ accredited BBB profile, and shows strong ratings on Google, Trustpilot, and TransportReviews. The positive evidence is broad, but it is not uniform: Yelp is substantially lower at 2.9★, and the audit identified at least one detailed no-show and poor-follow-up complaint. We recommend this broker for standard open transport, provided the customer confirms the pickup window, cancellation terms, carrier assignment, and total price in writing before paying.
Authority and company record
All State to State Auto Transport operates under the legal entity BISMILLAH TRANSPORT LLC. The August 2026 audit matched the public brand to MC-653413 / USDOT 2242737 and confirmed active FMCSA broker authority. Its website, phone numbers, and support email tested as working, and the company history was recorded at approximately 18 years. The identity and operating record are consistent, although the public profile was graded Partial rather than fully complete. Consumers should still verify current authority and insurance information directly through FMCSA before dispatch because federal status can change after an audit date.
Reviews and customer experience
The review record is strong overall but should be read platform by platform. Google was recorded at 4.8★ from 573 reviews, Trustpilot at 4.7★ from 434 reviews, and TransportReviews at 5.0★ from 67 reviews. BBB lists an A+ accredited profile with one complaint recorded in the audit and a Low complaint signal. Yelp is the outlier at 2.9★ from 7 reviews. That sample is too small to outweigh the much larger Google and Trustpilot totals by itself, but the gap is still relevant because it shows that not every customer experience matches the dominant positive pattern. Customers repeatedly praise responsive representatives, clear updates, and delivery coordination. Communication and price honesty were graded Strong; pickup and problem handling were Mixed; delivery and willingness to use the company again were Strong. The principal caution is a detailed account involving a missed pickup and weak follow-up. A targeted search of attributable public court and regulator records did not identify a lawsuit or government enforcement action directly tied to BISMILLAH TRANSPORT LLC or All State to State Auto Transport as of August 29, 2026. That search result is not a guarantee that no private claim or local case exists.
Pricing and service fit
The audit classifies All State to State Auto Transport as a budget option with Low price-change risk. Pricing earned 13/15, including 4/5 for price consistency and 4/5 for bait-and-switch risk protection. Multiple reviews reportedly describe the company as standing by the quoted price and avoiding hidden fees. Customers should nevertheless require a written breakdown of the broker fee, carrier payment, cancellation rules, and any conditions that permit a price adjustment; a quote is not the same as a guaranteed carrier acceptance price unless the contract says so. The company is best suited to standard open transport. The audit graded open transport, enclosed transport, and urgent pickup as Strong; inoperable-vehicle transport as Mixed; and luxury or classic-vehicle transport as Weak. Route and service evidence totaled 7/10. For high-value, modified, or collectible vehicles, customers should compare enclosed-carrier insurance limits and handling procedures rather than relying on the overall broker score alone.
Transparency and brand signals
The company has a functioning website and established contact infrastructure, but its brand-transparency score was 9/10 rather than perfect. The strongest trust signals are the matched FMCSA identity, long operating history, accredited BBB profile, and high-volume reviews. The remaining gaps are the Partial profile grade, the small but sharply negative Yelp sample, and limited public detail about how unusual claims or missed pickups are escalated. The safest booking approach is to preserve the quote, dispatch sheet, carrier details, and all text or email communications.
Positive signals
- Active FMCSA broker authority under MC-653413 / USDOT 2242737
- 4.8★ Google rating across 573 reviews
- BBB A+ accredited profile with a low complaint signal
What to verify
- Yelp rating is 2.9★, although the sample is only 7 reviews
- At least one detailed no-show and poor-follow-up complaint was identified
- Public-profile completeness was graded Partial in the August 2026 audit
Auto Haul Express LLC or AutoCarShip LLC
49/100 · Limited Confidence · Audited August 26, 2026
Auto Haul Express LLC, also marketed as AutoCarShip, scores 49/100 — Limited Confidence — and is not currently recommended. FMCSA authority is active and several review platforms contain strong positive feedback, but the audit found High price-change risk, Weak price honesty, Weak problem handling, and a detailed allegation that a quoted price roughly doubled after a deposit. The company also uses multiple public-facing names, which makes identity verification more important. This is not a finding that the business is a scam; it is a conclusion that the evidence is too mixed and the operating history too short for a recommendation.
Authority and company record
AUTO HAUL EXPRESS LLC is registered under MC-1618777 / USDOT 4197700 and was shown as holding active FMCSA broker authority in the August 2026 audit. AutoCarShip is presented in the company’s terms as a trade name of Auto Haul Express LLC. The website, phone, and email tested as working, but identity consistency received only 2/5 because customers and public pages use Auto Haul Express, AutoCarShip, and in at least one account a similar Auto Haul Movers name. The company had roughly two years of operating history, so its long-term complaint and resolution record is still developing.
Reviews and customer experience
The review profile is mixed rather than uniformly poor. Google was recorded at 4.8★ from 37 reviews, TransportReviews at 5.0★ from 24 reviews, Trustpilot at 4.1★ from 197 reviews, and Yelp at 3.2★ from 13 reviews. Positive accounts often name helpful booking agents and describe timely delivery. The audit found no BBB profile, so there is no BBB grade or complaint-resolution history to use as a cross-check. Review consistency scored only 1/3, and overall complaint severity also scored 1/4. Communication, pickup, delivery, and willingness to use the company again were graded Mixed; price honesty and problem handling were graded Weak. The most important complaint described a deposit followed by a price increase that allegedly brought the total to roughly twice the initial quote. That is a customer allegation, not a court finding, but it directly supports the High price-risk classification. A targeted search did not identify a public lawsuit or government enforcement action directly attributable to AUTO HAUL EXPRESS LLC or AutoCarShip as of August 29, 2026. That does not prove no private or local case exists.
Pricing and service fit
This broker is marketed as a budget option, but pricing earned only 5/15. Price consistency and bait-and-switch protection each scored 1/5, and the final audit applied a six-point medium penalty. Before paying, customers should demand a written breakdown of the broker fee, carrier payment, refund conditions, and the exact events that permit a price change. If the document allows the broker to increase the price whenever a carrier does not accept the quote, the advertised amount should be treated as an estimate rather than a guaranteed total. Standard open transport is listed as the primary use case, but open transport itself was graded Mixed. Enclosed transport and urgent pickup were graded Strong; inoperable-vehicle transport was Mixed; luxury or classic transport was Weak. Route and service evidence totaled 5/10, including only 1/3 for route-relevance confidence. Customers should verify that an actual carrier has accepted the route and price before relying on a pickup date.
Transparency and brand signals
The working website and contact channels are positive, but the brand score was 6/10. The largest transparency issue is name consistency: Auto Haul Express LLC is the legal entity, while AutoCarShip is the customer-facing trade name, and similar names appear in reviews. The absence of a BBB profile and the short operating history reduce the amount of independent resolution evidence available. Consumers should match every contract, payment recipient, MC number, and dispatch notice to AUTO HAUL EXPRESS LLC / MC-1618777 before proceeding.
Positive signals
- Active FMCSA broker authority under MC-1618777 / USDOT 4197700
- 4.8★ Google rating across 37 reviews
- 5.0★ TransportReviews rating across 24 reviews
What to verify
- High price-change risk with a detailed allegation that the quoted price roughly doubled after deposit
- Price honesty and problem handling were both graded Weak
- Operates across Auto Haul Express and AutoCarShip names, creating identity confusion
Before you book
Get the terms in writing
Ask each broker for the total price, deposit and cancellation terms, pickup window, carrier information when assigned, cargo coverage, and how price changes are handled. A strong audit profile does not replace reading the agreement for your specific shipment.